Vital Football

Latest Crewe Alexandra News

Donaldson - A Hibees Eye View

Donaldson - A Hibees Eye View

We wanted to know if Donaldson would be a worthwhile signing and a good replacement for Maynard. So we asked Hibs Davie from the Vital Hibernian site for his views.

This is what he had to say...

Donaldson arrived from York City last summer and John Collins, then Hibs boss, suggested he'd been bought as much as one for the future rather than as an player who would immediately slot into a first team role however he was involved from the bench from the start of the season.

Fan opinion of him is divided as it probably will be once he eventually moves on. He scored 5 goals for the Hibees - 3 of which were in one SPL clash against Kilmarnock albeit two of his strikes were penalties. He should have had four but missed another penalty!

The best match of his Easter Road career was in a CIS Cup defeat to Motherwell when he scored a wonder goal, finishing well after a mazy 30 yard run. That's one of the problems with Donaldson - sometimes you feel he has the makings of a decent player and other times he looks like a bad Sunday pub team player. His favoured position is centre forward although he can play on the right hand side of midfield as a winger.

Plus points are his speed and unpredictability while the biggest negatives are his slight frame and lack of natural ability.

Since the arrival of Mixu Paatelainen as manager in January, Donaldson has found himself completely out of the picture, rarely even making the bench and seemed to know his time was up at the club after hitting out at his lack of opportunities in a recent newspaper interview saying 'I had an indication they were probably going to listen to offers, because basically I haven't really been playing."

'With the manager changing, it hasn't helped at all. It's absolutely killed it for me, really. I was enjoying myself under John Collins, but a new manager has come in with his own opinions, which is fair enough. I think that was the turning point where it started to go downhill for me. I don't think I've started a single game under the new manager."

'It's disappointing because you want to play every game as possible, but I've not had much of a chance. I'd rather have been judged on opportunities given to me, but I haven't. I've just had to bite my tongue."

'There has been interest from other teams. It's up to the club if they accept an offer. As far as I'm concerned, I'm still a Hibs player and I'm still going to fight for my place as long as I'm here. I'm not really looking too far into that because I've seen it all before. You just never know what can happen in football. One minute you're not in the plans, then you score a hat-trick and you're back in favour.'

Paatelainen has told 8 or 9 Hibs squad members that they are not good enough to play for the club and it would appear Donaldson is one deemed surplus to requirements.

One definite plus point is his girlfriend Pippa Fulton who once appeared on BBC's Fame Academy - she's definitely better than Clayton!

Hibs Davie
Vital Hibernian


Thanks Hibs Davie for your views!!

You can see a 'trademark' Donaldson penalty in the YouTube video below.













Join the FREE Telegraph League One Fantasy Football League!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:pastymaster
Date:Monday August 4 2008
Time: 9:11PM

Login to post a comment

Recent Crewe Alexandra Articles

Ray's Ray of Hope

Josh Ravenscroft talks about George Ray being back in contention for a first team place.

Crewe Alex: The Realisation

The Crewe board know we need to change now. Read on for more

Crewe Alex: Jordan Bowery

Josh Ravenscroft talks about new signing Jordan Bowery, and what his impact will be.

Riley Explains Postponements

It doesn't happen often in the Premier League or Championship thesedays, but League's 1 & 2 still suffer the odd postponement owing to the weather and Mike Riley...

Archived Vital Crewe Articles

Vital Crewe articles from

Site Journalists

Nicky Crompton
Editor email
Profile
Ross Menhennet
no email
Profile
Steven Dale
no email
Profile
Josh Ravenscroft
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Would a 'target man' be benificial for Crewe Alexandra?
Suggested By: Josh Ravenscroft
Yes88%
No12%

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Doncaster 26 17 4 5 55 19
2 Plymouth 25 16 3 6 51 14
3 Carlisle 26 12 11 3 47 11
4 Portsmouth 26 13 6 7 45 14
5 Wycombe 25 12 6 7 42 6
6 Luton 25 11 8 6 41 13
7 Colchester 26 11 7 8 40 10
8 Cambridge 25 11 6 8 39 9
9 Barnet 26 10 9 7 39 0
10 Exeter 25 11 3 11 36 9
11 Grimsby 26 10 6 10 36 2
12 Blackpool 25 9 8 8 35 11
13 Crawley 25 10 5 10 35 -7
14 Mansfield 26 8 10 8 34 -3
15 Stevenage 26 10 3 13 33 -4
16 Yeovil 25 8 7 10 31 -3
17 Morecambe 25 9 4 12 31 -11
18 Crewe 26 6 10 10 28 -11
19 Hartlepool 26 6 9 11 27 -11
20 Leyton Orient 26 7 4 15 25 -11
21 Accrington 25 6 7 12 25 -11
22 Cheltenham 25 5 9 11 24 -10
23 Notts County 26 6 5 15 23 -20
24 Newport 25 4 6 15 18 -16
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Crewe Alexandra Results (view all)

Crewe Alexandra Fixtures (view all)

Jan 21 2017 3:00PM : Doncaster Rovers (a)
Sky Bet League Two
Jan 28 2017 3:00PM : Cheltenham Town (H)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 4 2017 3:00PM : Exeter City (a)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 11 2017 3:00PM : Grimsby Town (H)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 14 2017 7:45PM : Wycombe Wanderers (H)
Sky Bet League Two
Feb 18 2017 3:00PM : Blackpool (a)
Sky Bet League Two

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Cainley1
The Vital Football Members League